More A5902 Twists and Turns
Posted: Sat, 2024-Jul-27 8:49 pm
I've finally made some headway on my papertrail and it shifted my research a little eastward into Kildare. It turns out my McLains were around Clane (go figure) Co. Kildare, going back and forth to Dublin until obtaining a 1772 lease of 100 acres in Lehinch, Co. Offaly, and to make a long story short (after having to read several books), The 8th Earl of Kildare obtained MacLean "redshanks" via his very close friend and ally Aedh Ruadh O'Domhnaill who was bringing in MacLeans just about every fighting seasons beginning in the 1480s.
FT130287 has been a wild goose-chase, mostly because I'm trying to make the DNA make sense which it doesn't. All four branches of FT130287 have Leinster papertrails, which I thought was purely a coincidence, and I could never figure out the outlier, Mr. Fraher. Once I figured out we were a non-Breifne clade, I've been trying trying to connect the dots between point A (Maigh Seola) and C (Midlands) and i thought it logical that point B would be somewhere between the two maybe in the era of surnames developing. My research late last year into this year of 'Mac an Leagha' in Tir Maine, ended up being a wash after the individuals I found as "McLane" appeared later in their lives as "McLea" so it seems that it was a mistake on part of the writer and not an anglicization. I began to re-focus on my own papertrail and also the Gorry/Gurry angle of research which still could have been a number of surnames. Even after finding my ancestors in Kildare and starting to realize that FT130287 could have always been in Leinster (mysteriously), I threw in the towel for a little while, and then Bernard Morgan found a reference to "Guairi m. Dubhdacrich m. Brenainn" in the Book of Ballymote Ui Briuin genealogies. Although it's pretty clear Guaire was most likely a more distant descendant, not only did this confirm just exactly who Gorry & Gurry are, but that FT130287 (c.910-1000ad) was an O'Guaire, and it was possible we all are (as Fraher has no relation to any other Waterford families). When I started to examine the entire O/Mac Guaire surname population, a picture started to develop. It appeared to me that:
1. The heaviest concentration of this surname is E. Offaly/W. Kildare, particularly Clonbullogue, Co. Offaly-Rathangan, Co. Kildare, and at the time of FT130287's lifespan, this area would have all mostly been in the kingdom of Ui Failge, which was seated at Rathangan until the Norman incursion.
2. This was likely a very old surname, and multiple dense population clusters would indicate these people were scattered some time ago from wherever they originated (Viking age? Norman invasion?).
I began to look into placenames that might reflect an earlier population in this area of interest, and this may be a coincidence but they were rather close. Plotted out with MDKAs and earliest records of each surname, a Clongorey (Cluain Guaire: Guaire's Meadow) in Feighcullen parish and a Tullygorey (Tulach Mhic Guaire: McGuaire's Hillock) south of the area near Athy. Tullygorey is first recorded in the Calendar of Justiciar Rolls in 1297, and could be either a surname or just a personal reference to a "son of Guaire". However this supports that this is a very old surname, and the placename of Clongorey is older. Very interestingly in the parish of Killybegs (outside Clane) where my MacLeans had settled in The Cott, the 1654 civil survey when describing the borders of this parish noted a 'Loughgurry', however it's not on any 18th c. maps, it was probably drained like many lakes were to increase arable land. There was not a trace of any O'Guaires here in any record except this placename, which makes me wonder if events in the area 1550-1650 wouldve created O'Guaire orphans that were taken in by friends or maternal kin. I'm fairly certain this is my branch's place of settlement, as the Extent of Monastic Possessions notes in 1540 that "the tenants of Killybegs are exempt from all exactions save coigne and livery, and enjoy 100 acres of common pasture" for quartering of the lord's mercenaries (the coigne and livery system), and it's a very good contender for the place of the NPE.
I'm quite stumped on how or why FT130287 came to be here. Going into the annals and genealogies, Guaire certainly seems to be a popular given name c.700-c900. Concentrating in Leinster, there were abbots of Clonfad and Glendalough of the name, several lords of the Ui Ceinnsealaigh in the 9th c. were "sons of Guaire" although it was a patronymic and not a surname. However there are two entries in the Annals of Four Masters where Guaire is a surname.
962. Cairbre Ua Guaire, head of the hospitality of Leinster, died.
"head of hospitality" seems to have usually been used to denote a taoiseach, however I think it could also be a position high in the church as well. This man is not in the book of Leinster, so the latter is probably more likely. The next entry gives a little more information on another Ua Guaire.
1032. Tadhg Ua Guaire, lord of Ui-Cuilinn, was slain by the son of Mael-na-mBo.
The individual doing the slaying was certainly Dermot mac Mael-na-mBo, a lord of Ui Ceinnsealaigh who later became the King of Leinster. There are several entries about him in this timeframe eliminating his rivals. But who were the Ui Cuilinn?
This is the only annals entry naming them, and I first thought it was either the Ui Mail septs of Ui Cellaig Cuallan or Ui Briuin Cuallan. The Ui Cellaig Cuallan were certainly involved in some scraps in the area, and stopped an invasion from Meath at Claonadh (Clane) in 704. However these words were not pronounced like Cuillin"(middle Irish: "Coolin" or "Cooleen"). And the Ui Mail genealogies held by MacFirbis were all published in the History of the Clan O'Toole, and not one Guaire, nor Ua Guaire appears in any part of it.
I then remembered that Clongorey was in the parish of Feighcullen (Fiodh Cuillin), a parish mostly within Ui Failge, which Clongorey is detached from for some reason. As usual, the history of the placename is a little vague. Cuillin/Chuillin is usually denoted as "of the holly tree". But could certainly be a person or group. There is an ecclesiastical settlement in Feighcullen, whose patron is found in the Martyrology of Tallaght.
800. St. Beohan, Bishop of Fiodh-cuillin, in Ui Failge; Of the race of Ui Faelain, whose feast day is 8 Aug
The nearby church of Kilcullen then, could also reference a person or group, however I think it's been settled on "Church of the Holly Tree" because of the pattern of church names in the area (Cill Dara: Church of the Oak).
Two references to Kilcullen barony, one in The Origin and Stem of the Irish Nation give other origins, although not necessarily the church: “Coille Culluin (or the Woods of Cullen), now the barony of Kilcullen in the County Kildare.” and in The History of Ireland by James MacGeoghegan: “Coille-Cuillin, a territory on the frontiers of the counties of Wicklow and Kildare, the patrimony of the O’Culluins, of the race of Cahir-More, by his son, Fiacha Baicheada.”
Cahir Mor was also the ancestor of the Ui Failge, however their genealogies are quite questionable (Rus Failge is noted as his son but the annals show three centuries between them), and I also dont know how much stock to put in the information as these authors don't give a source. But certainly placenames referencing both Guaire and Cuilinn are extremely interesting... Could it be that "Coill Cuilinn" lies somewhere on the eastern fringes of the Ui Failghe in the vicinity of all three of these places?
Going back to the timeframe of Tadhg Ua Guaire being killed by Diarmaid mac Mael-na-mBo, an AFM entry 5 years later noted the Ui Ceinnsealaigh lord's activity near Kilcullen...
1037. Ruaidhri, son of Tadhg Ua Lorcain, Tanist of Ui-Ceinnsealaigh, was taken prisoner in the Daimhliag of Cill-Cuilinn, by Donnchadh Mac Gillaphadraig; and he was afterwards blinded by the son of Mael-na-mbo.
It's still unclear who the Ui Cuilinn were, or where there territory was, they were probably insignificant and had a temporary window of strength that made them a rival. However a 12th century poem about Rathangan notes an Ui Failge king named Cuilen..
The fort over against the oak-wood,
Once it was Bruidge’s, it was Cathal’s,
It was Aed’s, it was Ailill’s,
It was Conaing’s, it was Cuiline’s,
And it was Maelduin’s.
The fort remains after each his turn,
And the kings asleep in the ground.
The Cuilen in question was killed in an intercine conflict in Coolcor, Co. Offaly in 652
652. The conflict of Cúil Corra in which Cuiléne son of Forannán fell. Mael Deich and Onchú were victors
So whether this is really who the Ui Cuillin are, were the Ua Guaires here a dynastic kin group that could be descended of Brenainn? Given the surname concentration on the Offaly/Kildare border tied to the Guaire m. Brenainn in the Book of Ballymote, and the placenames denoting 'Cuilinn' and 'Guaire' within the cluster, it would seem to support that FT130287 may be connected to the Tadhg Ua Guaire in AFM1032. I really cannot figure out how or why, but what comes to mind is the O'Connor placing the O'Fallon in Tir Maine to suppress the Ui Maine, but I think that's quite a stretch for possibly a High King of Ireland to take a sept from Connacht and place them in Leinster. They could also have just fled Maigh Seola with the rest of A5902+ and muscled their way into another area, and *somehow* become lords of an already-existing kin group (Ui Cuilinn).
FT130287 has been a wild goose-chase, mostly because I'm trying to make the DNA make sense which it doesn't. All four branches of FT130287 have Leinster papertrails, which I thought was purely a coincidence, and I could never figure out the outlier, Mr. Fraher. Once I figured out we were a non-Breifne clade, I've been trying trying to connect the dots between point A (Maigh Seola) and C (Midlands) and i thought it logical that point B would be somewhere between the two maybe in the era of surnames developing. My research late last year into this year of 'Mac an Leagha' in Tir Maine, ended up being a wash after the individuals I found as "McLane" appeared later in their lives as "McLea" so it seems that it was a mistake on part of the writer and not an anglicization. I began to re-focus on my own papertrail and also the Gorry/Gurry angle of research which still could have been a number of surnames. Even after finding my ancestors in Kildare and starting to realize that FT130287 could have always been in Leinster (mysteriously), I threw in the towel for a little while, and then Bernard Morgan found a reference to "Guairi m. Dubhdacrich m. Brenainn" in the Book of Ballymote Ui Briuin genealogies. Although it's pretty clear Guaire was most likely a more distant descendant, not only did this confirm just exactly who Gorry & Gurry are, but that FT130287 (c.910-1000ad) was an O'Guaire, and it was possible we all are (as Fraher has no relation to any other Waterford families). When I started to examine the entire O/Mac Guaire surname population, a picture started to develop. It appeared to me that:
1. The heaviest concentration of this surname is E. Offaly/W. Kildare, particularly Clonbullogue, Co. Offaly-Rathangan, Co. Kildare, and at the time of FT130287's lifespan, this area would have all mostly been in the kingdom of Ui Failge, which was seated at Rathangan until the Norman incursion.
2. This was likely a very old surname, and multiple dense population clusters would indicate these people were scattered some time ago from wherever they originated (Viking age? Norman invasion?).
I began to look into placenames that might reflect an earlier population in this area of interest, and this may be a coincidence but they were rather close. Plotted out with MDKAs and earliest records of each surname, a Clongorey (Cluain Guaire: Guaire's Meadow) in Feighcullen parish and a Tullygorey (Tulach Mhic Guaire: McGuaire's Hillock) south of the area near Athy. Tullygorey is first recorded in the Calendar of Justiciar Rolls in 1297, and could be either a surname or just a personal reference to a "son of Guaire". However this supports that this is a very old surname, and the placename of Clongorey is older. Very interestingly in the parish of Killybegs (outside Clane) where my MacLeans had settled in The Cott, the 1654 civil survey when describing the borders of this parish noted a 'Loughgurry', however it's not on any 18th c. maps, it was probably drained like many lakes were to increase arable land. There was not a trace of any O'Guaires here in any record except this placename, which makes me wonder if events in the area 1550-1650 wouldve created O'Guaire orphans that were taken in by friends or maternal kin. I'm fairly certain this is my branch's place of settlement, as the Extent of Monastic Possessions notes in 1540 that "the tenants of Killybegs are exempt from all exactions save coigne and livery, and enjoy 100 acres of common pasture" for quartering of the lord's mercenaries (the coigne and livery system), and it's a very good contender for the place of the NPE.
I'm quite stumped on how or why FT130287 came to be here. Going into the annals and genealogies, Guaire certainly seems to be a popular given name c.700-c900. Concentrating in Leinster, there were abbots of Clonfad and Glendalough of the name, several lords of the Ui Ceinnsealaigh in the 9th c. were "sons of Guaire" although it was a patronymic and not a surname. However there are two entries in the Annals of Four Masters where Guaire is a surname.
962. Cairbre Ua Guaire, head of the hospitality of Leinster, died.
"head of hospitality" seems to have usually been used to denote a taoiseach, however I think it could also be a position high in the church as well. This man is not in the book of Leinster, so the latter is probably more likely. The next entry gives a little more information on another Ua Guaire.
1032. Tadhg Ua Guaire, lord of Ui-Cuilinn, was slain by the son of Mael-na-mBo.
The individual doing the slaying was certainly Dermot mac Mael-na-mBo, a lord of Ui Ceinnsealaigh who later became the King of Leinster. There are several entries about him in this timeframe eliminating his rivals. But who were the Ui Cuilinn?
This is the only annals entry naming them, and I first thought it was either the Ui Mail septs of Ui Cellaig Cuallan or Ui Briuin Cuallan. The Ui Cellaig Cuallan were certainly involved in some scraps in the area, and stopped an invasion from Meath at Claonadh (Clane) in 704. However these words were not pronounced like Cuillin"(middle Irish: "Coolin" or "Cooleen"). And the Ui Mail genealogies held by MacFirbis were all published in the History of the Clan O'Toole, and not one Guaire, nor Ua Guaire appears in any part of it.
I then remembered that Clongorey was in the parish of Feighcullen (Fiodh Cuillin), a parish mostly within Ui Failge, which Clongorey is detached from for some reason. As usual, the history of the placename is a little vague. Cuillin/Chuillin is usually denoted as "of the holly tree". But could certainly be a person or group. There is an ecclesiastical settlement in Feighcullen, whose patron is found in the Martyrology of Tallaght.
800. St. Beohan, Bishop of Fiodh-cuillin, in Ui Failge; Of the race of Ui Faelain, whose feast day is 8 Aug
The nearby church of Kilcullen then, could also reference a person or group, however I think it's been settled on "Church of the Holly Tree" because of the pattern of church names in the area (Cill Dara: Church of the Oak).
Two references to Kilcullen barony, one in The Origin and Stem of the Irish Nation give other origins, although not necessarily the church: “Coille Culluin (or the Woods of Cullen), now the barony of Kilcullen in the County Kildare.” and in The History of Ireland by James MacGeoghegan: “Coille-Cuillin, a territory on the frontiers of the counties of Wicklow and Kildare, the patrimony of the O’Culluins, of the race of Cahir-More, by his son, Fiacha Baicheada.”
Cahir Mor was also the ancestor of the Ui Failge, however their genealogies are quite questionable (Rus Failge is noted as his son but the annals show three centuries between them), and I also dont know how much stock to put in the information as these authors don't give a source. But certainly placenames referencing both Guaire and Cuilinn are extremely interesting... Could it be that "Coill Cuilinn" lies somewhere on the eastern fringes of the Ui Failghe in the vicinity of all three of these places?
Going back to the timeframe of Tadhg Ua Guaire being killed by Diarmaid mac Mael-na-mBo, an AFM entry 5 years later noted the Ui Ceinnsealaigh lord's activity near Kilcullen...
1037. Ruaidhri, son of Tadhg Ua Lorcain, Tanist of Ui-Ceinnsealaigh, was taken prisoner in the Daimhliag of Cill-Cuilinn, by Donnchadh Mac Gillaphadraig; and he was afterwards blinded by the son of Mael-na-mbo.
It's still unclear who the Ui Cuilinn were, or where there territory was, they were probably insignificant and had a temporary window of strength that made them a rival. However a 12th century poem about Rathangan notes an Ui Failge king named Cuilen..
The fort over against the oak-wood,
Once it was Bruidge’s, it was Cathal’s,
It was Aed’s, it was Ailill’s,
It was Conaing’s, it was Cuiline’s,
And it was Maelduin’s.
The fort remains after each his turn,
And the kings asleep in the ground.
The Cuilen in question was killed in an intercine conflict in Coolcor, Co. Offaly in 652
652. The conflict of Cúil Corra in which Cuiléne son of Forannán fell. Mael Deich and Onchú were victors
So whether this is really who the Ui Cuillin are, were the Ua Guaires here a dynastic kin group that could be descended of Brenainn? Given the surname concentration on the Offaly/Kildare border tied to the Guaire m. Brenainn in the Book of Ballymote, and the placenames denoting 'Cuilinn' and 'Guaire' within the cluster, it would seem to support that FT130287 may be connected to the Tadhg Ua Guaire in AFM1032. I really cannot figure out how or why, but what comes to mind is the O'Connor placing the O'Fallon in Tir Maine to suppress the Ui Maine, but I think that's quite a stretch for possibly a High King of Ireland to take a sept from Connacht and place them in Leinster. They could also have just fled Maigh Seola with the rest of A5902+ and muscled their way into another area, and *somehow* become lords of an already-existing kin group (Ui Cuilinn).